-
Pham Binh added a new comment in A Reply to Pham Binh and Clay Claiborne: Imperialism in a Bell Jar?"...the White House has lifted an unofficial embargo on its Gulf allies sending heavy weapons to the rebels." http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/middleeast/syria/10131063/Syrian-rebels-get-first-heavy-weapons-on-the-front-line-of-Aleppo.html
-
-
Pham Binh replied to a comment in A Reply to Pham Binh and Clay Claiborne: Imperialism in a Bell Jar?It's not even clear what your point is citing those slogans or what you're objecting to. lol
-
Pham Binh replied to a comment in A Reply to Pham Binh and Clay Claiborne: Imperialism in a Bell Jar?I suppose when you sneeze and someone says "God bless you," you denounce them as a Christian fundamentalist, right?
-
Allah is Sufficient as a Supporter, Bread and Blood, There Is No Terrorism in Syria Except that of Assad, Rebels and Merchants Hand in Hand Until Victory, God’s Order Has Come so Don’t Hurry it, Death Rather than Humiliation -- I'll remember to hi
-
Pham Binh added a new comment in A Reply to Pham Binh and Clay Claiborne: Imperialism in a Bell Jar?Eric writes: "Pham.. I'm interested to hear what you think that these videos show. Is it simply the fact the masses of people are on the streets? Aren't there many reactionary populist movements that do that? For instance, I noticed in that second vi
-
Pham Binh added a new comment in A Reply to Pham Binh and Clay Claiborne: Imperialism in a Bell Jar?Here's a video of <i>women</i> leading protests against Jabhat al-Nusrah in Raqqa, a city controlled by Islamist militias in the north: https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=9hOsyH7zasw
-
Keith added a new comment in Productive Forces Determinism? Yes!Mark, I am not entirely certain I understand your questions. But, I will try. You ask "what job?" Just about any job (by job here I mean useful work) is made easier and can be accomplished in less time at higher levels of productive force developm
-
Keith added a new comment in Reading Capital and rejecting productive forces determinismNat thanks for clarifying. I think you are right that the way I am using the base/superstructure distinction is confusing because it deviates from tradition and leaves out the kinds of things you mention: courts, police, gov’t, etc -- what Althusser
-
Mark C added a new comment in Productive Forces Determinism? Yes!"The second pointy is: the higher the level of the productive force the less time it takes to do a job." But what job? And is one that should be done?
-
Nat Winn added a new comment in Reading Capital and rejecting productive forces determinismKeith, Of course exchange value is a category, the primary category, that reflects the capital (social) relation. This is not where the issue lay as far as I see it. Every example you have given, in every recent article you have written, describes
-
Some video footage of a demonstration?
-
eric ribellarsi is friends with Dennis Potter
-
eric ribellarsi replied to a comment in A Reply to Pham Binh and Clay Claiborne: Imperialism in a Bell Jar?Pham.. I'm interested to hear what you think that these videos show. Is it simply the fact the masses of people are on the streets? Aren't there many reactionary populist movements that do that? For instance, I noticed in that second video, that ther
-
Cuz arms shipments and bombing campaigns are so enlightened?
-
Thanks for the blog post. There's very interesting history and ideas there. I absolutely disagree with you on this question.
-
Pham Binh replied to a comment in A Reply to Pham Binh and Clay Claiborne: Imperialism in a Bell Jar?Not a revolution? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D_lmEtyL_Ts http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zus8rKYx3JE http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D_lmEtyL_Ts 10 points if you can spot any imperialists or Saudis.
-
http://louisproyect.org/2013/06/17/imperialism-counterhegemonic-blocs-and-the-syrian-revolution/
-
Keith added a new comment in Reading Capital and rejecting productive forces determinismNat, I feel like we are talking past each other a bit. We are starting the discussion at a very high levels of abstraction. I would like to take a step back for a minute. Marx starts with the commodity. Maybe we could start there too. We agr

